Skip to main content

NSSE’s 20th Anniversary Reveals Promising Trends in Engagement

Anniversaries are a good time to reflect on change and stability over time. As NSSE enters its third decade surveying hundreds of thousands of college students each year, we can take a long look back to identify any trends. Certainly, much has happened in higher education since NSSE’s launch in 2000 - the assessment of teaching and learning has gained in sophistication, […]

Mar 10, 2021
featured-image-7
featured-image-7

Bob Gonyea – Anniversaries are a good time to reflect on change and stability over time. As NSSE enters its third decade surveying hundreds of thousands of college students each year, we can take a long look back to identify any trends. Certainly, much has happened in higher education since NSSE’s launch in 2000 - the assessment of teaching and learning has gained in sophistication, new technologies have transformed our institutions, and perhaps most importantly, more institutions have made firm commitments to evidence-informed improvement.

NSSE itself has changed over time. Manyitems on the questionnaire have been added,substantially revised, or dropped over the years - particularly with the majorupdate in 2013 - but a few dozen items have remainedunchanged or changed in only minimal ways. We combined these into alongitudinal file using data from 2004 to 2019 representing 1,583 U.S.institutions that participated in NSSE between 2004 and 2019. We selected 2004 as thebeginning year because the questionnaire underwent frequent changes and NSSEhad fewer participants in the early years. Annually,the number of institutionsranged from 461 (2004) to 725 (2008), averaging about 580 per year. The totalnumber of respondents from this time period is over 5 million, ranging annuallyfrom 158,943 (2004) to 434,149 (2011) with an average of 316,770 respondentsper year.

Colleges and universities thatparticipate in NSSE deserve credit for taking their engagement resultsseriously and doing the hard work of changing practice to positively affect thequality of their students’ experiences.

Weidentified three engagement areas that appear to have increase consistentlyover time, and that did not seem to be affected by the 2013 survey update: (a) first-yearinteractions with faculty, (b) time spent on academic preparation, and (c) perceptionsof the campus environment.

Interactionswith Faculty in the First Year of College

First-yearstudent interactions with faculty have trended positively in three practices:talking about career plans, discussing course topics outside of class, and workingwith faculty on activities other than coursework (Figure 1). Indeed, the portionof first-year students who interacted frequently (very often or often) in theseareas each increased by more than 10 percentage points over the time span. Thismay indicate that by and large, faculty who teach first-year students have devotedmore effort to having meaningful conversations with students outside of theclassroom - a form of engagement that helps to socialize new students, supportstheir persistence, and facilitates their ongoing development.

Figure1. First-Year Student Interactions with Faculty 2004-2019

TimeSpent in Academic Preparation

Studentsalso appear to have spent more time on academic preparation than they did overa decade ago, although this upward trend has slowed in recent years (Figure 2).For example, the percentage of first-year students who spent more than 15 hoursper week preparing for class (studying, reading, writing, doing homework or labwork, etc.) increased from 34% in 2004 to as high as 45% in 2017. Seniorsmatched this pattern, also increasing about 10 percentage points and levelingoff recently. These increases amount to as much as two more hours per week forall students on average. Spending more time on academics is a positive outcome,whether the result is from higher expectations, more emphasis on collaborativelearning, or wider adoption of new instructional methods such as flipped classrooms,problem-based learning, or real-world application.

Figure2. Time Spent in Academic Preparation 2004-2019

This isan encouraging finding, because previous NSSE analyses found that at theinstitutional level, the average amount of time that first-year students devoteto academic preparation is positively correlated with both retention andgraduation rates.

Perceptionsof the Campus Environment

Finally,two positive trends in perceptions of the campus environment were spotted. First,students increasingly rated the emphasis on diverse interactions as substantial(very much or quite a bit), with the trend rising more than 10 percentagepoints for both first-year students and seniors, with most of the increases inthe earlier years (roughly 2004 to 2012) (Figure 3). For example, seniors’perceptions of substantial institutional emphasis on diverse interactions increasedsteadily from 43% to 55%. Support for helping students manage their nonacademicresponsibilities such as work or family also increased from 23% to a high of33%, leveling off in more recent years. Such results are encouraging consideringthe changing demographics of higher education, with historicallyunderrepresented and nontraditional-age students enrolling in larger numbers.

Figure 3.Seniors’ Perceptions of the Campus Environment 2004-2019

These results provide a high-altitudeview of engagement trends over time. As with any study, limitations exist. Forexample, the sample of institutions represented in each annual cohort varies.Some question wording changed over the years, especially with the survey updatein 2013. The effect of such changes varies, sometimes in unknown ways. Inaddition, the order of the items changed from the original survey (2012 andearlier) and the updated survey (2013 and after), which also may affectresponses. This analysis examines individualsurvey questions rather than NSSE’s EngagementIndicators because item changes in the 2013update preclude the possibility of tracking multi-item scales over time.

Yet, we are confident that institutionssee improvement in areas that they measure and attend to as a priority. Ofcourse, not all items on the survey have increased as substantially, if at all,but we find it promising to observe growth over 16 years in meaningfulinteractions with faculty, time devoted to academic work, and aspects of thecampus environment. Colleges and universities that participate in NSSE deservecredit for taking their engagement results seriously and doing the hard work ofchanging practice to positively affect the quality of their students’experiences.

Note: These results were first reported in the NSSE Annual Results 2019.

Author

More stories